Category Archives: General Real Estate
A client asked me the other day, "what do you think rates are going to do"? The underlying question is, "should we rush to list, sell and buy now, or can we be more deliberate (and sane), and wait until Spring? What will interest rates be next week, next month, in the Spring? The markets - real estate, mortgage, stock - change. Frequently. I'm good at what I do, and part of what I do is to know what I'm good at (real estate), who's good at what they do, and help my clients assemble the right team. So my answer to the question was to ask an expert - local lender Matt Hodges. There's more to the answer than "up, down, sideways ..." Thanks, Matt for the background, the answers and the history.
Where are Interest Rates Going?
As a loan officer, I get that question often. It’s not that I don’t want to answer it – I do, usually with a comment like “If I knew, I’d be a rich man trading bonds.” But, I can’t answer the question in the manner that it was asked. “Where are rates going, Matt?” Before I give you my prediction for short term rate movements, after all it is an educated guess, let’s describe the underlying basis for mortgages, look at recent and not so recent history and let’s see what experts think will happen.
Fixed rate mortgages is really what we care about when discussing the future. Adjustable Rate Mortgages (ARMs) will nearly always be lower than fixed and follow an index called LIBOR – London Interbank Offered Rate, which is currently in the .5% range. That’s why current ARMs are adjusting downwards from their start rate to around 2.75%-3%. Forget ARMs – they are the exception not the rule for the mortgage world.
Fixed rate mortgages and specifically those sold to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or Ginnie Mae investors get pooled with other like loans – 30 year fixed, 80% loan to value, 750 or better FICO score for example – and sold to investors. Investors treat this investment much like you would consider an investment in the stock market.
Will prices go up and yields on the bonds go down over time and therefore my investment today will be worth more tomorrow to another investor? Or will the interest paid on the mortgage each month be a better investment than something else in the investor’s pool of opportunities? Since repayment of mortgages is front loaded – interest averaging about 69% of the principal and interest in the first year – does that make a better rate of return? Investors are not shy about buying mortgage backed security bonds. They believe in the inherent stability of our housing stock.
The history of fixed rate mortgages has been historically affected by external economic forces. Economic forces include whether more Americans claim jobless benefits in any given week, whether the unemployment rate goes up or down, and who is participating in that labor pool, how many new government and private sector jobs have been created in any given month, consumer confidence, manufacturing, inventories and a myriad of other reports that bombard us nearly daily. More recently, we are also affected by non-United States economic forces like where the German Bund (their bonds) is moving. Recently, German 2 year Bunds have traded in negative territory.
What? You can’t have a negative rate of return, can you? Investors in German bunds are willing to lose principal right now, compared to riskier investments. That affects us because if German investors don’t think there’s good economic prospects – say to purchase corporate bonds for a German manufacturing company, then US investors have less confidence in the US economy – Germans buy less of our exports – and hence they purchase more bonds, pushing the price up and the yields down. That affects your mortgage rate, pushing it down.
Mortgages have also been affected by intentional actions of governments. In the United States, the most recent and visible is Quantative Easing (QE). To simplify it to the most recent experience of QE III, in September, 2012, the Federal Reserve authorized the purchase of $45 billion of treasury bonds and $40 billion of mortgage backed securities EVERY month, indefinitely. The current Federal Reserve’s Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) on Wednesday released a statement at the conclusion of their regularly scheduled two day meeting that the last of the QE buying has now ended. What happened in this interval with rates? For that answer, you actually have to look back a year or so. Anticipation of QE by investors is almost more powerful than the actual announcement. Rates merely improved slightly post announcement, but had been falling for the previous year by almost 1% in rate. The reason QE is powerful is that the government creates an artificial marketplace for bonds. That is, the Fed has decided that yields are too high to stimulate growth and therefore all investors will be forced to buy bonds at higher prices and accept lower yields, because the Fed is the 800 pound gorilla in the room. Their hope is that investors look to corporate issuances of debt – lets build more factories, employing more Americans, etc. More recently, Europe’s flirtation with QE has affected us as well. But, because they are many countries in the European Union (EU) and they lack a strong leader in Mario Draghi, often their announcements are met with indifference.
One of the voices in my head is Adam Quinones, Head of Mortgages and ABS at Thomson Reuters. He postulated on Tuesday in his daily email to bond traders and others in the industry, “Janet (Yellen, Fed Chair) would have to officially downgrade her global growth outlook (in order for rates to keep moving lower)” and “…dealers become the buyer of last resort again.” As discussed, as dealers are replacing the Fed, the artificial market is removed. Will dealers still enjoy low yields? Or, perhaps better stated, will dealers see an opportunity to swap bonds up and down the curve – from 26 week bills to 30 year bonds to make profit short or long term?
One of the smartest guys I know in the business is Matthew Graham, Chief Operating Officer for Mortgage News Daily and MBS Live and featured on CNBC from time to time. Today he made a seemingly odd movement in bonds rallying, while GDP print came in stronger than estimates – both treasuries and MBS – understandable to the masses: “Quite simply, European bond markets are in the midst of a strong rally this morning. Over the longer term, a super strong European bond market has helped to generally drag US rates lower than they otherwise would be. “
Janet Yellen, Federal Reserve chair since February, in question and answer period of the press conference after release of Fed Announcement in September: "You are certainly right in saying that over a number of years now, there’s been a pattern of forecast errors in which either we’ve been on track with respect to unemployment or unemployment has come down in some cases faster than we anticipated, and yet growth has pretty persistently been surprising the Committee to the downside. And that is a statement about productivity growth, which has been pretty disappointing. So we have had downward revisions in the level of potential output and to some extent, at least for a time, in the projected pace of growth."
Okay, here are my thoughts. Virtually everyone I’ve read has predicted rates near or above 5% in the next 12 months. I don’t see it. I think volatility will be a constant – gyrations of rate movements tied to stock market swoons or dips or automated trading models picking up key words, causing a sell or a buy. While rates are in the low 4% range for conventional and mid 3% range for government, I don’t think we’ll see 5%. For Conventional loans, in the next three months, my range is 3.75% - 4.25% or mostly lower in range than current market. In the next six months, bets are off. We could be anywhere in a more-than-full point range, say 3.5% - 4.75%.
Twelve months from now, no worse than 4.75%, but that would be only a small chance. I make these comments not because I’m filled with Hopium, but because I think there are underlying problems with proclaiming our 5.9% unemployment rate as improving, when participation rates are so low. When job seekers fall off the radar at 99 weeks of unemployment, they aren’t counted any more. I think that Europe will have continual structural and employment problems. I think that as Chair Yellen has stated, the Federal Reserve is often wrong with their optimism.
Matt Hodges Charlottesville Sales Manager Presidential Mortgage Group NMLS #295347
In a first (that I'm aware of) in Charlottesville - bicycle garages! **
They just make sense, particularly as the neighborhood in which these townhomes are being built is right in Downtown Charlottesville, is a 6 minute bicycle ride to the Mudhouse on the Downtown Mall.
Today's post made me look back at a post I wrote nearly 8 years ago, in which I responded to a reader who wrote about there being, essentially "two Charlottesvilles" - those who live in the City and those who don't.
Bicycle garages are evidence of the growing ability to live entirely in the City of Charlottesville if you so choose.
** This might seem like an ad for Southern Development, as 1) I'm a real estate agent and 2) my firm, Nest Realty, represents Southern Development but really, I just think these are cool. I was having a conversation on Twitter about the Burnet Commons 2 neighborhood and wondered why I hadn't written about the bicycle garages before.
Is the "Recovery" Leading to a Boom in Real Estate Agents (in Virginia)?
There’s a sweet spot for productivity. Too few and you’re not (in my opinion) truly competent; in the words of an agent from whom I’ve learned a lot over the years, “if you’re not doing enough business, you’re not screwing up enough to learn.” Experience matters; every transaction, every person, every situation is different. If you’re doing too many, the customer is going to feel (and be treated like) a number rather than a human - a person making a big freaking life and financial decision - the right balance of productivity is critical.
Think about this:
- about 10% of the licensed real estate agents are new, some of whom are likely experienced agents from other states, but in general, new.
- In my opinion, if a new agent is mentor-less, he or she is not remotely qualified to represent a client.
- As the real estate market recovers, more agents will enter the profession.
- Hopefully we never return to 2006 numbers.
- I’m going to cover some of this in more detail in this month’s Monthly Note, focusing on the consumer’s responsibility when vetting and hiring representation.
For some context, in Charlottesville there are about 900 Realtors:
- 672 have done at least a half a side (co-representing either buyer or seller)
- 289 have done at least five sides this year
- 149 have at least 10 sides
- 66 have at least 15 sides
- 44 have at least 20 sides
Credit to Calculated Risk for the idea and Virginia’s DPOR for emailing me the data - quickly!
I've said for years that if you're in the Charlottesville area and are thinking about selling your home in the Spring, you should be having pictures taken of your home Now. If you decide in the dead of winter and want exterior photos taken those pictures will be of a desolate landscape - and that doesn't look so great to potential buyers.
Also, if you're thinking about selling, now is the time to start truly learning the market, evaluating comps, and determining whom to hire to represent you.
If you have questions or would like a recommendation for a photographer (or a market analysis), please ask me.
Me? I was somewhat surprised at how few found their new home via real estate agents ... but upon reflection, not really.
For years I've written and said that a good real estate agent's skillset is far, far more than having a login to the MLS and a lockbox key (although I'd argue that that's the primary skillset for at least half of licensed real estate agents).
A great real estate professional helps buyers (and sellers) put together puzzles, serves as a guide - a navigator of the market, and a filter and interpreter of the seemingly endless morass of purportedly relevant information available. Searching for homes online is easy; ascertaining whether that home is the right one for you is often much more difficult.
Heck, in 2007, I wrote about 12 reasons to to use a Realtor.
With that preface, have some fun with the data the NAR just put out about where buyers find homes.
A friend wrote some time ago that part of finding success is to give a sh*t.
Giving a sh*t is hard. But it's rewarding and meaningful. This post? Not about real estate, other than that a tremendous component of "real estate" is community.
Just over nine years ago, I started RealCrozetVA with a simple goal -"to provide a forum for Crozet to (hopefully) discuss their thoughts about Crozet’s growth." At the time of the blog's inception, Crozet was smaller, Old Trail hadn't yet begun, the new Crozet Library was still being designed, and there was palpable concern, and questions, about what was happening.
In the past nine years, a lot has changed. Facebook and Twitter, for example, didn't exist. Now those channels have become major components of the RealCrozetVa communication voice. I've never spent the time to figure out a "strategy" per se, but some things are more appropriate for Facebook, some for Twitter, and I've started a "recently on facebook" category on the blog to archive the conversations there.
Two thoughts on the changing technology - 1) I wish I'd done a better job of archiving photos of Crozet. 2) One of the constants in this journey has been WordPress.
The Crozet Gazette launched a few years ago and has provided consistently great reporting, something I'm just not going to do.
I'd love to be able to make some changes to the design (like add an "add to calendar" button) but that's likely to not ever happen by me.
But really? The "success" of RealCrozetVA is thanks to the community's involvement, their comments, likes, replies, etc.
Have I "gotten business" from RealCrozetVA? Maybe, but that's never, ever, been the goal. I occasionally write about the Crozet real estate market (46 posts in 9 years - about 3% of the time), merely as a reminder that I do happen to earn a living as a real estate agent.
One thing that is absolutely critical is Blue Ridge Internetworks who provide the hosting and support for RealCrozetVA for free. Thank you. (I'd get their fiber to my house if I could)
I'm grateful for the community in which I live, and hope to continue writing about it for some time.
* I'm always looking for guest posters, though!
Ello. The newest, greatest social network that's hoping to supplant Facebook. I hope they succeed. But what is it? (what's this have to do with real estate? Not much, other than real estate is in part a social business, and ello is social.)
I'm still figuring Ello out, and it's a bit fun to be in the early days of something new and somewhat undefined. The loneliness there is a bit different from the loneliness I perceive on Google +; to me, Ello is new while G+ is tried and mostly failed.
But really, I signed up in order to further my lifelong battle to be thought of as Jim Duncan from Charlottesville rather than Jim Duncan the weatherman.
NB: My blog is in transition right now; the tag isn't working, so to read the rest, click here.