CAAR Economic Summit – Localized Market Data

I’ve spent the day at a Charlottesville Realtor Economic Summit, and the following was a very good presentation by Barry Merchant, the chief economist for the Virginia Housing Development Authority.

More analysis will come later this evening, but I wanted to put this up in the meantime.

CAAR Conference VHDA Economic outlook

The entire presentation on Thursday was impressive, but Barry Merchant’s stood out for its relevance to our market – the Charlottesville real estate market – the high-level overview was excellent, but when looking at economic data and information, the “local” is key.

Thoughts on the slides –

– On the Credit Suisse scary ARM slide – some of these ARMS might just reset down, rather than up.
– On the “trailing NoVa” slide – this is what I have been telling clients for a few months now – the Charlottesville market seems to track about nine to twelve months behind the Northern Virginia market … we may have a little ways’ to go before we experience a “turn” similar to the one they are seeing now.
– There’s plenty of blame to go around. Rather than seeking to place blame, we need to instead focus on the causes, and ensure that we don’t repeat these mistakes caused by greed and short-sighted (policy) decisions.

Mr. Merchant’s four points warrant reiterating in their entirety:

We must re-instill the confidence of first-time homebuyers

1. The industry must work together to motivate qualified potential buyers in the face of uncertain employment and declining home prices
– This requires a common focus on the core values of homeownership that derive from the traditional idea of “one’s home as one’s castle” rather than the recent notion of housing as an investment tool—
– Security of tenure
– Stability in housing costs arising from long-term,fixed rate financing
– Pride of ownership and control of one’s living environment

2. We must avoid unintended stimulus consequences
– The current crisis resulted from excessive market stimulation
– Loose lending from 2004 to 2007 was a short-term expedient to maintain high home sales and loan volume following the peak of the trade-up and refinance booms earlier in the decade
– The industry must avoid new stimulus measures that will wreak further market damage when the props are later removed

3. We must manage the return of prices to sustainable levels
– The housing industry cannot achieve full recovery until prices return to historic norms
– However, a rapid drop in prices is itself destabilizing to the market
– Our challenge is to avoid a price “crash” without unduly subsidizing artificially high prices

4. We must build consensus on sustainable means for meeting future housing needs (bolding mine)
– Pent-up demand is growing—the longer and deeper the recession, the greater pent-up demand will be
– We lack the right mix of housing types in the right locations to address future demand—The uncertain long-term ownership of distressed properties further complicates the balance of supply and demand
– The housing industry needs to find a new consensus with government on the regulatory structure and subsidy support needed to sustain a thriving post-recession housing sector

“The right mix of housing types in the right locations …” simple, poignant and wildly accurate, and warrants a follow-up post in and of itself.

*This post remains a work in progress … thankfully, my time this week has been limited by work with buyers and sellers … please bear with me and I welcome your thoughts and questions.

(Visited 140 times, 1 visits today)


  1. Real C'ville - The Bubble Blog March 26, 2009 at 20:35

    Jim, you are providing an enormous educational tool to sellers as well as buyers by linking to this info on your blog. This should be “required reading” for anybody thinking about selling, buying, or representing a seller or buyer of a home this season, IOHO. Many thanks for posting.

    Our current post is a Q&A with Jason Crigler of The Mortgage Buzz blog, Crown Mortgage Services. We’ve taken readers’ questions.

    There ARE folks who want to buy, and need to buy. But as the economic data indicates, it’s particularly difficult for Gen Y’s, the ostensible FTHBs. And ANY homebuyer is concerned about being immediately “under water” once the contract is signed. Add in the Baby Boomers’ recent loss of wealth via stock market and falling home values just as they contemplate retirement, plus tighter credit standards, especially for jumbo loans (many properties in this area need jumbos) and…it’s no wonder this market is stalled.

    To state the obvious, for anybody watching or participating in the local real estate market, this is going to be a truly fascinating selling season.

  2. other Jim March 27, 2009 at 10:28

    would that be Barry Merchant the WL professor?

  3. Jim Duncan March 29, 2009 at 20:59

    BB –

    Thanks. I really want buyers, sellers and Realtors in Charlottesville (and elsewhere) to be as educated and as informed as possible. It’s a shame that people are just now starting to pay attention and educate themselves … but it’s a real opportunity that we ought not shirk.

    other Jim –
    I honestly don’t know.

  4. Pingback: What Do You Want to Know? | Real Central VA

  5. Pingback: VHDA Market Update for Charlottesville, Virginia region | Real Central VA

  6. Pingback: Barry Merchant’s Housing Update – October 26, 2011 | |

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *