Cash, not cash? A bit of local perspective on cash real estate transactions in the Charlottesville area.
The Washington Post just published an interesting story about cash real estate transactions. It would be more useful if you could go back and see the percentage of cash transactions over the past five years.
Last year (2018), same timeframe, 1140 had sold. So a fairly significant increase in volume. But the one reason I pulled this number for the pod was that this year, of that 1278, 310 have sold with cash. And last year, almost 300 had sold with cash, so fairly consistent. That’s the one data point in the MLS in that house sold perspective that I think is fairly accurate. The other ones between ARMS and fixed-rate mortgages and stuff are not always properly selected.
Purchases in Charlottesville have been about a third of the market for several years.
And just because a transaction is marked as a “cash” transaction does not mean that it is actually “cash” — meaning a wire from buyer’s account to the seller for the purchase price.*
* (it wouldn’t work that way, anyway, as the buyer would wire to their attorney, who would wire to the seller’s attorney, who would wire to the existing mortgage holder if there was one, and the remainder to the seller)
I’d say that at least half of my “cash” clients have gotten loans.
Especially when rates were sub-4%, I had clients who would guarantee that they could pay cash if necessary, but many if not most ultimately got loans.
A Buyer putting forth a “cash” offer:
a) eliminated financing/appraisal contingencies and often (but not always) out-competed offers with financing contingencies.
b) stated they had the potential to be financially liquid if they had to be. (but they really didn’t want to be).
c) often created headaches because in reality, lenders were still just as involved as in a pure cash transaction. We even developed clauses that stated explicitly that if the buyer was putting forth that they were a cash buyer, and still got a loan, they were obligated to close on time as the seller likely had a purchase dependent on the first transaction closing on time. Dominoes are everywhere.
d) usually was fine.
Keep in mind also that ~40% of American homeowners don’t have mortgages
“About 37 percent of households in the U.S. are living without mortgages.
The share of homeowners paying off their mortgages has increased by 5.5 percentage points over the past decade, according to Bloomberg, citing data from Zillow. This is in part due to an aging population of homeowners, as younger Americans tend to wait longer to buy property thanks to factors like student debt and increasing living costs. The trend could reverse as younger people start to enter the real estate market.”
I find that often, when I make comments on local social media or Twitter, it’s useful to capture those thoughts here. God help me trying to find a random Reddit or Twitter comment.
Interested in Learning More?
Jim Duncan has been helping buyers and sellers in Charlottesville’s neighborhoods for 25 years. Get local insight born of experience.
Dig Deeper
How’s the Charlottesville Market? In August 2026
How’s the Charlottesville market in mid-August 2026? I ran into a client the other day I’d not seen since they bought and sold their homes seven years ago. They’re a bit removed from it, the way most people are when they’re not actively buying or…
Recapping July’s Charlottesville Real Estate Reddit AMA
Doing these AMAs is a highlight of every quarter. I learn something every time, get great questions, and hopefully help answer questions and educate people. Plus, doing these forces me to research and vet the information every time. I am sure I make mistakes, but…
End of June 2026 Charlottesville Real Estate Market Status
If 2026's Charlottesville real estate market is anything like last year's market, we still have a ways to go -- ~40% of this year's listings haven't come on the market yet. I was going to wait until first week of July to write this so…
Two Weekends Tell the Story of Charlottesville’s 2026 Spring Market
One of the most important stories of the 2026 Charlottesville real estate market remains pricing + velocity. 82% of homes listed this year that went under contract went under contract in 30 days or less. In Charlottesville + Albemarle, 914 resale homes have been listed…